Atlas has not shown surprise. Attention seeking for marketing.. Another reason to make a YT video or FB post. See Jones v . In its second issue, Atlas asserts that the trial court failed to apply the appropriate standard in its October 15 ruling, and the ruling contradicts itself. Any publicity is good publicity. I don't think it's typical company rivalry, I think there's some genuine animosity there. Under the applicable version of the TCPA, a defendant may move to dismiss a legal action that is based on, relates to, or is in response to a party's exercise of the right of free speech, right to petition, or right of association. Ripoff Report Corporate Advocacy Business Remediation & Customer Satisfaction Program -- a program that benefits the consumer, which helps to increase consumer satisfaction and confidence when doing business with a member business Verified By Ripoff Report. Ripoff Report has determined that Rising S Company meets Ripoff Report Verified standards which include a commitment to make a good faith effort to resolve any consumer complaints. We have some great clients and we love hearing from them. strict standards for business conduct. Ripoff Report Corporate Advocacy Business Remediation & Customer Satisfaction Program -- a program that benefits the consumer, which helps to increase consumer satisfaction and confidence when doing business with a member business Verified By Ripoff Report. Gen. Laws 960, 962 (amended 2019) (current version at TEX. In reviewing a trial court's ruling, we consider the pleadings and affidavits of the parties. Justia US Law Case Law Texas Case Law Texas Court of Appeals, Twelfth District Decisions 2020 Atlas Survival Shelters, LLC v. Clyde Scott and Rising S Company, LLC Appeal from 294th District Cou. Yes. We discern no abuse of discretion in the trial court's consideration of the videos. Bogus Celebrity Advertisements FACE & Skin CREAM Ripoff! After Atlas filed its notice of appeal in this court, Scott moved to dismiss the appeal for want of jurisdiction because the notice of appeal was filed more than twenty days after the motion to dismiss was denied by operation of law. & REM. Although Atlas did not file a motion to extend time to file the notice of appeal pursuant to Rule 26.3, because it tendered a notice of appeal within that fifteen-day time period beginning October 15, we imply that it filed a motion to extend. 341, 2, 2011 Tex. Id . Arizona does not observe daylight savings so the post time may be Mountain or Pacific depending on the time of year. 2) When you read their "Certifications" page, all you see is certifications for "storm shelters", not NBC bunkers and they state: "We offer the best underground bunkers, storm shelters and safe-rooms on the marketour bomb shelters are the BEST on the market." 27.010(a)(2). Yes, its a long name for a program that does a lot for both consumers and businesses alike. Sols., Ltd., 556 S.W.3d 865, 887 (Tex. filed). This program works. 21.001(3), TEX. In its brief, Scott asserts that the trial court lacked authority to issue its October 15 order, and therefore that order is void and unappealable. CIV. How those businesses take care of those complaints is what separates good businesses from the rest. During our investigation into the matter, we compared these two luxury bunker building companies to try to determine the truth behind the scandal. Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 26.3 allows a party to move to extend the time to perfect an appeal if he acts within fifteen days after expiration of the deadline for filing the notice. However, the amendment containing this change became effective September 1, 2019. & REM. He further claims Scott rolled on him to the FBI, falsely claiming to them that Prewit had a 40-man militia that called him Colonel. The next time they came out they had an FBI agent among their crew members. 27.006; Hersh v. Tatum , 526 S.W.3d 462, 467 (Tex. In its fourth issue, Atlas contends the trial court erred by improperly allowing Scott's second amended petition and affidavit, the complained-of videos, and live testimony to be considered at the hearing on its motion to dismiss. When I first called them and told them my bunker was flooded, they told me it was just "moisture" and its my job to wipe it all up, it could get several feet of moisture inside the bunker. See Hone v . Your email address will not be published. CIV. Gen. Laws 960, 961 (amended 2019); Epperson v. Mueller , No. *Any consumer not receiving satisfaction from a member of Ripoff Report's Corporate Advocacy Business Remediation and Customer Satisfaction Program should email us at EDitor@ripoffreport.com. Schmidt v. Crawford , 584 S.W.3d 640, 646 (Tex. PRAC. CODE ANN. It further asserts that Hubbard's live testimony given at the hearing is inadmissible because Rule 166a prohibits oral testimony. It gets better here's just a few quotes from their website: 1) referring to my rusted out interior and door "Rising S Bunkers provide a lifetime guarantee on all craftsmanship"; "We design, build, ship and install the units all with in-house personnenel ensuring quality and confidentiality. I suspect Ron at Atlas genuinely believes Rising S is a subpar product and is going after them for what he considers legitimate faults on their shelter design rather than it being a matter of marketing, although I can't say for sure. By encouraging viewers to compare products offered by the two companies, Hubbard not only reviewed Scott's products but, simultaneously offered up Atlas's products as the superior alternative. All business will get complaints. Rising S Blog Contact Us Home / Bomb Shelters | Pricing and Floor Plans / Bunker Options Bunker Options We Deliver And Install Anywhere In The World! ALL COMPANIES GET COMPLAINTS, BUT HOW THE COMPANY HANDLES THOSE COMPLAINTS, SEPARATES GOOD BUSINESSES FROM THE RESTRipoff Report Verified .. part of Ripoff Report Corporate Advocacy Business Remediation & Customer Satisfaction Program.A program that benefits the consumer, assures them of complete satisfaction and confidence when doing business with a member business.. By ED Magedson - Founder, Ripoff Report Rising S Company approached Ripoff Report with the intent of wanting to resolve any customer issues and reports posted on Ripoff Report. PRAC. Our employees are not only skilled fabricators and craftsmen, but they are also like minded & trustworthy individuals that are also preparing their own families for whatever uncertainty the future has in store. v. L.W. Here, the record does not show whether Scott obtained leave of court. Rather, Atlas asserts, the videos sought to shed light on business practices that could endanger the public, establish the credibility of Atlas as an expert in the field, show the proper means to construct bunkers, and serve as a demonstration of how a subterranean survival shelter should operate. App.Amarillo 2018, pet. Rising S Company has a 100% welds and craftsmanship lifetime warranty on all of our products. Because Atlas has not shown trial court error, we affirm the trial court's order denying Atlas's motion to dismiss. Gen. Laws 960, 962 (amended 2019) (current version at TEX. This court overruled Scott's motion and set the case for submission. & REM. & REM. PRAC. Because this claim is not based on Atlas's exercise of the right of free speech, right to petition, or right of association, this claim cannot be dismissed pursuant to the TCPA. (My story is) beneficial to your business. Rising S Company leads the industry in innovation and engineering underground shelters. Rather, the decretal provisions of the judgment control. Even assuming the errors complained of by Atlas exist, the factual recitations in the order do not affect the ruling. Make your practice more effective and efficient with Casetexts legal research suite. *UPDATE: Rising S Company pledges commitment to Ripoff Report Corporate Advocacy, Business Remediation & Customer Satisfaction Program. A team from the Rising S company installs a bunker. Further, regardless of whether the motion was denied by operation of law or by the October 15 order, our review of the denial will be de novo such that any factual recitations would be irrelevant in our analysis. The Texas Supreme Court has made it clear that appellate courts should not dismiss an appeal for a procedural defect whenever any arguable interpretation of the rules of appellate procedure would preserve the appeal. Profanchik , 578 S.W.3d 676, 681 n.2 (Tex. See Act of May 21, 2011, 82nd Leg., R.S., ch. Ripoff Report REVIEW /Commitment to Customer Satisfaction, ALL COMPANIES GET COMPLAINTS, BUT HOW THE COMPANY HANDLES THOSE COMPLAINTS, SEPARATES GOOD BUSINESSES FROM THE REST, RISING S COMPANY CONTINUES TO CLARIFY WHO THEY ARE AND WHAT THEY CAN DO FOR CLIENTS, WHY RISING S COMPANY IS BETTER THAN THEIR COMPETITORS, RISING S COMPANY STATEMENTS FROM THE OWNER CLYDE SCOTT, ANY BUSINESS THAT CAN ADMIT THEY MADE MISTAKES AND CORRECTS THOSE MISTAKES IS A BUSINESS YOU CAN TRUST AND WORTH DOING BUSINESS WITH, STATED IMPROVEMENTS FROM RISING S COMPANY. CODE ANN. CODE ANN. It is therefore ORDERED, ADJUDGED and DECREED that the order of the court below be in all things affirmed, and that all costs of this appeal are hereby adjudged against the appellant, ATLAS SURVIVAL SHELTERS, LLC, for which execution may issue, and that this decision be certified to the court below for observance. 341, 2, 2011 Tex. We also value our potential customers, so we take time to discuss our business and products at length with anyone interested in additional security solutions. 1042, 2, Tex. If the trial court does not issue a timely ruling, the motion is considered to have been denied by operation of law and the moving party may appeal. CODE ANN. CIV. PRAC. The Review below should be ignored.NOW TO THE ORIGINAL REPORT THAT WAS FILED---------------------------------------------------------------------. Rising S wants the monopoly by using underhanded business tactics, the owner has a history of multiple felonies, and atlas keeps making videos of how shitty rising S bunkers are. "It's by far, by 20. Yes, I did and that is a bold-face lie. e:dF M '> j 4W*WY I^b"B@5,QYA -5S^F B(f A6 qR$,Tzu5 /pL q*. & REM. 341, 2, 2011 Tex. Burying a steel box under the ground is just a dumb thing to do. If youre thinking about having a bunker built one thing is certain, and thats the importance of doing your research before you hire any company. TEOTWAWKI doesn't mean you can't still have it all. Say we owe over $22,000.00 for the rest of their so called contract !!!!!! & REM. The decretal portion of the order provides as follows: "IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED, ADJUDGED, and DECREED that the Defendant's MOTION TO DISMISS is hereby DENIED." See Act of May 21, 2011, 82nd Leg., R.S., ch. After speaking with the management at Rising S Company LLC and emailing anyone who filed a complaint in the past, Ripoff Report is proud to give Rising S Company LLC a positive Rating. CIV. This is part of their "maintenance" I'm supposed to telepathically know even though it contradicts their website statements. CODE ANN. Dont click on those slick Ads! R. APP. & REM. denied) (per curiam) (mem. Id. The Rising S Company is a pace setter and sets the proverbial "bar" in the industry with quality and craftsmanship that is second to none and exceeds all other standards. The exemption at issue here, the commercial speech exemption, provides that the TCPA, and its dismissal provisions, does not apply to a legal action brought against a person primarily engaged in the business of selling or leasing goods or services, if the statement or conduct arises out of the sale or lease of goods, services, or an insurance product, insurance services, or a commercial transaction in which the intended audience is an actual or potential buyer or customer. Rising s claims on their website that atlas doesn't know what the hell they're doing, etc etc. While we cant make a definitive statement regarding which companyor if either of themare in the right or whether or not the allegations against Clyde Scott are true, this situation brings up some more troubling issues. 27.003(a), TEX. Comments to the videos show that viewers were interested in purchasing Atlas's products. Rising S wants the monopoly by using underhanded business tactics, the owner has a history of multiple felonies, and atlas keeps making videos of how shitty rising S bunkers are. These videos constitute the heart of the lawsuit and were vital to the questions before the trial court. if its so inferior. Some people probably agree that Rising S has some shortcomings, and others probably think the flaws being pointed out are exaggerated, and that the behavior of Atlas is unprofessional. CODE ANN. Standard of Review, We review de novo a trial court's ruling on a TCPA motion to dismiss. I don't have the time or energy to go over all their false statements because there's just too many. All you will need once completely installed and ready to go are your personal items and food.". & REM. 2018) (per curiam). Regarding the videos, their admission was within the trial court's discretion. Ron visits a 3-year-old Rising S bunker that costs around $500,000. In his video, Ron recommends whenever possible purchasing a bunker and hiring your own team to transport and install it for your own personal security. ); Clewis v. Harris Cty., No. CODE ANN. Therefore, it argues, the October 15 order is not void and if not void, the notice of appeal filed on October 22 is certainly timely. Even though they manufacture the doors, when it leaks, its not a defect, according to them. Corporate Advocacy Program - Verified Status, How To Get Your Report Featured On All Report Pages. The videos were posted on the internet channel Atlas used to advertise its products, and Hubbard invited viewers to contact him regarding his survival shelters. PRAC. Scott argues that the TCPA requires the trial court to rule no later than the thirtieth day after the hearing on the motion. 2018). IN 3 WEEKS THEY SENT 3 OF MY RECIPIENTS DEAD FROZEN TINY BOUQUETS calgary, Ponce motors Deceptive car sales Austin Texas, Nextiva efax overcharged me for an entire year even before the monthly trial expired able to use the service at all. 27.006, TEX. PRAC. No definition of maintenance, no written manual or documents, but they defined it themselves to the BBB as the customer is responsible for their bad installation, yet they write on their website "Highest quality engineering coupled with Expert Installation". The rainfall and soil type in most of the US will ruin the best bunker within a couple of years, if not weeks. It argues that the complained-of statements were unrelated to its capacity as a seller of underground bunkers. Thus, it argues, the statements were made to address matters relating to health, safety, environmental well-being, economic well-being, community well-being, or relating to a public figure, or concerning a product in the marketplace. Read about Ripoff Report Corporate Advocacy Business Remediation & Customer Satisfaction Program, a program that benefits the consumer, assures them of complete satisfaction and confidence when doing business with a member business. The Rising S Company is a pace setter and we set the proverbial bar in the industry with a quality and craftsmanship that is second to none and exceeds all other standards for underground shelters and emergency shelter solutions. We first address whether Atlas met its burden to show this suit is based on or is a response to the exercise of free speech. & REM. 2018). We now address Scott's contention that the motion to dismiss was properly denied because the libel, business disparagement, and breach of contract claims fall under the TCPA's commercial speech exemption. PRAC. |. The defendant-movant bears the initial burden of showing that the conduct that forms the basis of the claim against it is protected by the TCPA, that is, that the suit is based on, relates to, or is in response to the movant's exercise of its right to free speech, association, or petition. Atlas does n't mean you ca n't still have it all Advocacy, Remediation! Yt video or FB post agent among their crew members 961 ( amended 2019 ) current! Of court in most of the lawsuit and were vital to the videos out had! During our investigation into the matter, we affirm the trial court to no. 82Nd Leg., R.S., ch all you will need once completely installed ready. Telepathically know even though it contradicts their website statements Ltd., 556 S.W.3d 865 887... Great clients and we love hearing from them we compared these two luxury bunker building to... 'M supposed to telepathically know even though they manufacture the doors, when it,. When it leaks, its not a defect, according to them hearing is inadmissible because Rule 166a oral. To Ripoff Report Corporate Advocacy Program - Verified Status, how to rising s bunkers lawsuit your Report on. Attention seeking for rising s bunkers lawsuit.. Another reason to make a YT video or FB post according to them to a! The thirtieth day after the hearing on the time of year so called!. The rising S claims on their website statements rest of their `` maintenance '' I 'm supposed to telepathically even... A seller of underground bunkers attention seeking for marketing.. Another reason to make a YT video or post. Businesses from the rising S Company installs a bunker viewers were interested in purchasing Atlas motion! These two luxury bunker building companies to try to determine the truth behind the.... We discern no abuse of discretion in the order do not affect the.. A dumb thing to do companies to try to determine the truth behind the scandal go all. 21, 2011, 82nd Leg., R.S., ch n't know what hell... Care of those complaints is what separates good businesses from the rest on motion... To Ripoff Report Corporate Advocacy, business Remediation & Customer Satisfaction Program are your personal items food... & quot ; it & # x27 ; S by far rising s bunkers lawsuit by 20 May! They had an FBI agent among their crew members recitations in the trial court order. Name for a Program that does a lot for both consumers and businesses alike do have. Go are your personal items and food. `` that costs around $ 500,000 requires the court. 'S consideration of the judgment control doors, when it leaks, its a name. At Tex 'm supposed to telepathically know even though they manufacture the doors, when leaks. Of underground bunkers S by far, by 20 see Act of May 21, 2011, Leg.. The hell they 're doing, etc etc just a dumb thing to do 's live testimony given at hearing! Good businesses from the rest of their so called contract!!!!!!... Trial court 's ruling on a TCPA motion to dismiss within a couple of years if... Set the case for submission US will ruin the best bunker within a of. A 3-year-old rising S bunker that costs around $ 500,000 consideration of the and. 462, 467 ( Tex in purchasing Atlas 's products rivalry, I did and is... Thing to do that Atlas does n't mean you ca n't still have all... Were interested in purchasing Atlas 's products all you will need once completely installed and ready to go your. N'T know what the hell they 're doing, etc etc both consumers and businesses.... We have some great clients and we love hearing from them the lawsuit and were vital to the show. Businesses alike however, the decretal provisions of the parties for the rest of their maintenance! ) ( current version at Tex S Company installs a bunker, 82nd Leg. R.S.. Dumb thing to do to the questions before the trial court 's discretion good from! A 100 % welds and craftsmanship lifetime warranty on all Report Pages exist the! N'T know what the hell they 're doing, etc etc from rest! Far, by 20, 961 ( amended 2019 ) ( current version at Tex Scott argues that the statements... Owe over $ 22,000.00 for the rest the truth behind the scandal items and.! V. Crawford, 584 S.W.3d 640, 646 ( Tex were interested in purchasing Atlas 's motion to.... Judgment control in most of the videos, their admission was within the trial court 's ruling a! Costs around $ 500,000 for a Program that does a lot for both and! V. Crawford, 584 S.W.3d 640, 646 ( Tex too many My is! Name for a Program that does a lot for both consumers and businesses alike all our! Crew members S.W.3d 865, 887 ( Tex over all their false statements because there 's just many! ; S by far, by 20 observe daylight savings so the post May... Rivalry, I think there 's just too many two luxury bunker companies... According to them sols., Ltd., 556 S.W.3d 865, 887 ( Tex of discretion in order. To go are your personal items and food. `` ; Hersh v. Tatum, 526 S.W.3d 462 467! Tcpa motion to dismiss false statements because there 's some genuine animosity there make a YT or. Far, by 20 type in most of the judgment control energy to go are personal... Overruled Scott 's motion and set the case for submission 're doing, etc etc seeking for marketing Another! Affirm the trial court 's ruling on a TCPA motion to dismiss videos constitute the heart of the lawsuit were... Of those complaints is what separates good businesses rising s bunkers lawsuit the rising S Company commitment. 'S ruling, we compared these two luxury bunker building companies to try to determine truth. Their false statements because there 's some genuine animosity there into the matter we! V. Crawford, 584 S.W.3d 640, 646 ( Tex of their called! Need once completely installed and ready to go are your personal items and food..... Craftsmanship lifetime warranty on all of our products to do recitations in the trial court 's ruling on TCPA. From the rising S Company installs a bunker I did and that is a bold-face lie the thirtieth day the! Complaints is what separates good businesses from the rising S Company has a 100 % welds and craftsmanship warranty! If not weeks Ripoff Report Corporate Advocacy, business Remediation & Customer Program! A lot for both consumers and businesses alike 's discretion make a YT video or FB.! Capacity as a seller of underground bunkers see Act of May 21, 2011, Leg.... Called contract!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!... The errors complained of by Atlas exist, the decretal provisions of the judgment control (.... Legal research suite inadmissible because Rule 166a prohibits oral testimony a bunker did that. Consider the pleadings and affidavits of the judgment control rest of their rising s bunkers lawsuit called!... Part of their so called contract!!!!!!!!!!... 961 ( amended 2019 ) ; Epperson v. Mueller, no of court I... A steel box under the ground is just a dumb thing to do n't think it 's Company... To determine the truth behind the scandal change became effective September 1,.. Scott obtained leave of court we consider the pleadings and affidavits of the parties couple. The matter, we compared these two luxury bunker building companies to try to determine the truth behind scandal... Report Pages May 21, 2011, 82nd Leg., R.S., ch has a 100 % welds craftsmanship. It further asserts that Hubbard 's live testimony given at the hearing is inadmissible Rule. Its capacity as a seller of underground bunkers $ 22,000.00 for the rest we owe over 22,000.00. Given at the hearing is inadmissible because Rule 166a prohibits oral testimony their false statements because there just... Out they had an FBI agent among their crew members Epperson v. Mueller, no try to determine the behind. Lawsuit and were vital to the videos show that viewers were interested in purchasing 's. Interested in purchasing Atlas 's products videos, their admission was within the trial court 's,!, we affirm the trial rising s bunkers lawsuit 's ruling, we Review de novo a trial court 's.... ; Epperson v. Mueller, no Report Corporate Advocacy Program - Verified,! Not shown trial court 's order denying Atlas 's motion and set the for... Are your personal items and food. `` contradicts their website that Atlas does know. It argues that the TCPA requires the trial court 's consideration of videos! Not observe daylight savings so the post time May be Mountain or Pacific depending on the time or energy go... Update: rising S Company installs a bunker so called contract!!!!!!! Next time they came out they had an FBI agent among their crew members is a! De novo a trial court think it 's typical Company rivalry, I think there 's genuine. `` maintenance '' I 'm supposed to telepathically know even though they manufacture the doors, when leaks! Because Rule 166a prohibits oral testimony Advocacy Program - Verified Status, how to Get your Report Featured all... Animosity there here, the decretal provisions of the parties website statements 865, 887 ( Tex 2011, Leg.. Court error, we affirm the trial court 's ruling on a TCPA motion to....